Command to create rust-toolchain.toml in the current directory

[ian-h-chamberlain]

Apologies if this has already been requested, but I couldn't seem to find any issues describing something like it, nor any feature already built-in to rustup to do this. If there is, please feel free to close this issue.

Describe the problem you are trying to solve

Frequently, when I create a new binary project, I want to pin a specific toolchain immediately after initializing the project, e.g.

cargo new --bin some-project
cat >some-project/rust-toolchain.toml <<EOF
[toolchain]
channel = "stable"
EOF

However, I frequently forget the precise format of the toolchain file, and I have to search in rustup documentation to find an example and copy-paste that into my project. It would be nice if there was a simple way to generate a file with reasonable defaults that I could then customize, similar to the generated Cargo.toml created by cargo new or cargo init.

Describe the solution you'd like

Add one more more new rustup commands to create a rust-toolchain.toml in the current directory. I think this could work similarly to rustup override set (take a toolchain argument), or just use the default / currently-set toolchain. The generated file could also include comments that briefly describe some of the fields and link to the documentation.

Notes

Example of one possible workflow:

cargo new --bin some-project
cd some-project
rustup init nightly . # or whatever the syntax of the command looks like

After which the contents of some-project/rust-toolchain.toml would look like this:

# See more keys and their definitions at https://rust-lang.github.io/rustup/overrides.html#the-toolchain-file
[toolchain]
channel = "nightly"
components = []
targets = []
profile = "default"

Some possible command names:

• rustup new (for parity with cargo new)
• rustup init (possibly confusing with rustup-init)
• rustup generate-toolchain-file or similar (very wordy)
• rustup pin
• A subcommand or flag to pass to rustup override set ?

[0xPoe]

@rustbot claim

[tombh]

I got here from googling "rustup create rust-toolchain file". Surprised there isn't a command for this. Ever since I lost some time with an outdated rustc version I've religiously copy and pasted the rust-toolchain file. So agreed, I'd personally expect cargo init to do it. But equally wouldn't be surprised if the responsibility fell on rustup override set or similar.

[SuperKenVery]

I would personally prefer that cargo locks the rust toolchain. Even if that's not OK, a rustup lock or something similar would be great. The current approach is quite some drawback on reproducibility, I think.

[flipchan]

any update on this? Shouldn't be super hard to do

[bn-c]

+1